POWER LEARNING SOLUTIONS
  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Client Services
    • About Rob Power >
      • Meet Rob Power
      • CV
      • Leadership and Project Management
      • Research Background
      • Teaching and Instructional Design
      • Other Credentials
      • Artist Gallery
    • In the News
    • Social Media >
      • LinkedIn
      • Twitter
      • YouTube
    • Contact Us
  • Publications
    • Academic Publications
    • Blog
    • Books >
      • Blended Langauge Learning: Evidence-Based Trends and Applications
      • eLearning Essentials 2020
      • Everyday ID
      • Handbook of Mobile Teaching and Learning (2nd Edition)
      • IAmLearning
      • ID and Tech for Rapid Change
      • ID and Tech Vol 2
      • Mobile and ubiquitous learning: An international handbook
      • Operating System Fundamentals
      • Seamless Learning in Higher Education
      • Seamless Learning in Higher Educaton vol 2
      • Technology and the Curriculum: Summer 2018
      • Technology and the Curriculum: Summer 2019
      • Technology and the Curriculum: Summer 2022
      • Thriving Online: A Guide for Busy Educators
      • Fiction
    • Conference Presentations
    • Power Learning Daily News
  • Courses
    • Higher Education
    • K12
    • Open Courses
    • Professional Development
    • Digital Accessibility Webinar
  • Resources
    • Augmented Reality
    • BOPPPS-IT 2.0
    • CNIE
    • CSAM
    • Digital Accessibility
    • IAmLearn
    • IABL
    • ID Resources
    • Interactive RLOs
    • mLearn Conference Series
    • mLearn 2013
    • mLearning Vodcasts
    • mTSES
    • PETL
    • Videos
    • WebQuests

Group Work in Online Learning: The Good, The Bad, The Ugly -- and the Realities

9/17/2020

1 Comment

 
Picture
I typically include some form of group collaboration in the design of my online courses -- whether it be breakout activities during live class meetings, group presentations, or problem-based group projects. Every term, I invariably get some complaints from students, typically along the lines of:

  • I prefer to work alone.
  • I don't like being assigned to a group.
  • I prefer to pick my group members and our project topic.
  • Some group members are not pulling their weight / I'm doing all of the work.
  • I don't want my grade to suffer because of other group members.
​So -- If I get these types of complaints, why do I assign group activities? And why do I sometimes limit some of the choices that students have about which groups, topics, or group members they work with? (To be clear -- I frequently do give them time to sign-up for a group / topic of their preference -- but after a deadline I often need to assign students to a group, especially students who enroll late in a course.)
​One reason that I assign group activities is to help foster the development of a full Community of Inquiry in my online courses. Working with others helps to build Social Presence. Combined with my instructional design decisions, guidance, and feedback (Teacher Presence), this helps to maximize everyone's sense of belonging, and their Cognitive Presence in a course.
Picture
The Community of Inquiry Framework (Adapted from Athabasca University, 2016)
​Another reason that I assign group activities is because that is the way the world works outside of school. It is very likely that we will all -- at some point or another -- work as part of a team. Many times, the ability to work effectively within a team is written right into the descriptions of jobs we will be applying for! So, group work in online courses is good practice for "the real world."
​Now -- when we are working as part of team in "the real world," we are expected to work collaboratively towards a common goal. This is different from working cooperatively. Working cooperatively means that we may share a common goal, but we are simply "getting along" with each other and working together nicely. Working collaboratively means that we pool our expertise, resources, and efforts, to achieve that common goal. It does NOT mean that we all do exactly the same thing -- and sometimes some of us may feel like we are doing more than others on the team. And, let's face it -- sometimes we are! Sometimes, some team members do not contribute as fully as they could or should.
  • But, that's not fair! Why should they get the same grade as me? Why should my grade suffer because they won't do their share?
On the face of it, this sounds like a valid complaint. But, when we are talking about working as part of a team, it is actually a very individualistic (dare I say "self-centered" in the literal sense of the term -- not in a condescending way) perspective. In a team context, it is the team goals that matter, not individual goals. Don't get me wrong -- I'm not saying that we should let others "take advantage" of us, and create a life of stress for us as individuals. What I'm saying is that in group assignments -- just like team contexts in work environments -- we need to focus on achieving the immediate team goal. 
Sometimes, focusing on the team goal does mean that we end up doing more than what we feel is our fair share. But, our priority is the success of the team as a whole. We don't always know why some individuals are not contributing as fully as we would like them too -- and sometimes a "poor" performance on one team project can still be a valuable learning experience for the underperformer. They may still learn from the rest of the group (think of the Zone of Proximal Development), and be a much better "team player" the next time around. ​
PictureIncreasing learning potential in Vygotsky's zone of proximal development (adapted from Engström, 1987)
​

Or, they may not. It doesn't really matter that they get the same grade as you on one course assignment, or that they get acknowledged as part of the team at work. They know how much they contributed, as do other team members. While they may be "riding your coat tails" this time around, their performance and whether or not they improve as a team player over time will get noticed where and when it counts. It may not impact their current grade in a course -- but it will impact their ability to get favors from group members or coworkers, the ability to advance within the team environment, and possibly even their overall careers (if no one is willing to give them a good work reference!).
​I know that this sounds a bit corny -- but, if you're worried about your personal preferences or grades suffering because you've been assigned to work with a group -- focus on those team goals, on what's best for everyone in the team, on being a good collaborator and team leader -- and "take one for the team!"

References

Engström, Y. (1987). Learning by expanding: An activity-theoretical approach to developmental research. [Web page]. http://lchc.ucsd.edu/MCA/Paper/Engestrom/expanding/toc.htm

Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2000). Critical inquiry in a text-based environment: Computer conferencing in higher education model. The Internet and Higher Education, 2(2-3), 87-105. http://cde.athabascau.ca/coi_site/documents/Garrison_Anderson_Archer_Critical_Inquiry_model.pdf 
1 Comment
Jennifer Artan
1/20/2021 01:13:43 pm

Creating a sense of community in an online learning environment is a key part of the overall experience. I've been experimenting with breakout room features (Google Meets vs Zoom) to do group tasks, and so far, the feedback has been positive.

You said it, though - teamwork is a valuable real world skill. I haven't been back to my workplace in almost a year; all of our teamwork has been online. When students complain about groupwork, I like to point out that being able to work effectively in a team is great practice, but even better, when there is discord on that team, what a fantastic opportunity to learn resilience and to overcome challenges. At the very least, this experience is excellent fodder for that inevitable job interview question ("tell me about a time when you had to work on a team, but the team had personality conflict...").

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Power Learning Solutions: The Power to Access the World

    Author

    Rob Power, EdD, is an Assistant Professor of Education, an instructional developer, and educational technology, mLearning, and open, blended, and distributed learning specialist.
    More About Rob...

    Recent  Posts

    Categories

    All
    APA Formatting
    Augmented Reality
    Digital Accessibility
    EBooks
    EdTech
    Instructional Design
    Instructional Videos
    Learning Theoriies
    Mobile Learning
    Online Learning
    Open Access Resources

    Archives

    February 2023
    June 2022
    February 2022
    April 2021
    February 2021
    September 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    October 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018

    Older Posts from the xPat_Letters Blog

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About
    • About Us
    • Client Services
    • About Rob Power >
      • Meet Rob Power
      • CV
      • Leadership and Project Management
      • Research Background
      • Teaching and Instructional Design
      • Other Credentials
      • Artist Gallery
    • In the News
    • Social Media >
      • LinkedIn
      • Twitter
      • YouTube
    • Contact Us
  • Publications
    • Academic Publications
    • Blog
    • Books >
      • Blended Langauge Learning: Evidence-Based Trends and Applications
      • eLearning Essentials 2020
      • Everyday ID
      • Handbook of Mobile Teaching and Learning (2nd Edition)
      • IAmLearning
      • ID and Tech for Rapid Change
      • ID and Tech Vol 2
      • Mobile and ubiquitous learning: An international handbook
      • Operating System Fundamentals
      • Seamless Learning in Higher Education
      • Seamless Learning in Higher Educaton vol 2
      • Technology and the Curriculum: Summer 2018
      • Technology and the Curriculum: Summer 2019
      • Technology and the Curriculum: Summer 2022
      • Thriving Online: A Guide for Busy Educators
      • Fiction
    • Conference Presentations
    • Power Learning Daily News
  • Courses
    • Higher Education
    • K12
    • Open Courses
    • Professional Development
    • Digital Accessibility Webinar
  • Resources
    • Augmented Reality
    • BOPPPS-IT 2.0
    • CNIE
    • CSAM
    • Digital Accessibility
    • IAmLearn
    • IABL
    • ID Resources
    • Interactive RLOs
    • mLearn Conference Series
    • mLearn 2013
    • mLearning Vodcasts
    • mTSES
    • PETL
    • Videos
    • WebQuests